Issue:  Creating Final Surface & the Donut Hole

October 06, 2016 By Leo Lavayen Leave a comment

After a recent conversation with a longtime friend and Autodesk University Instructor, David Garrigues, I decided to post his interesting insight and content from one of his previous Autodesk University classes, on FG Corridor Surfaces.  The illustration below displays how pasting EG and FG to together to create a composite surface does not produce the expected or desired result.  These results are evident only upon creation of an entirely enclosed corridor, like in a Subdivision Layout, Pond, enclosed Berm or a moat.

Separate EG and FG surfacesFG-1Ar.jpg

Desired Composite Paste
FG-1Br.jpg

 

THE ISSUE:

Instead of a clean paste, as expected with a continuous contour, you will get a void in the enclosed area.  This results when using two boundaries: outer and inner (hide).

 Paste with VOID outcome (contours only style)FG-2Ar.jpg  Paste with VOID outcome (contours & tin style)FG-2Br.jpg

Or you might get straight triangulation across the gap, flattening out the EG conditions.

Paste with FLATTEN outcome (contours only style)
FG-3Ar.jpg
Paste with FLATTEN outcome (conturs & tin style)
FG-3Br.jpg

Both conditions created above result in false Contours and Earthwork Quantities. 

 

THE SOLUTION:

To create a single boundary that encloses the entire corridor design with ONE (1) polyline.  You need to play with where to cross in between corridor samples to loop in the void areas and wrap around the outer perimeter.

FG-4r.jpg

Upon creation of a single continuous boundary, assign it to the Corridor Surface, and the Composite Surface will build appropriately.

Correct Desired Composite Surface (contours only style)
 FG-5Ar.jpg
Correct Desired Composite Surface (contours & tin style)
FG-5Br.jpg

Hopefully, these steps will clear up any issues you may have seen in the past when building corridors and composite surfaces.

Tagged with Tech Support, Infrastructure, Surface, Civil 3D, PASTING SURFACES, akn_include

About Leo Lavayen

Cary, NC Infrastructure Technical Consultant

Something Powerful

Tell The Reader More

The headline and subheader tells us what you're offering, and the form header closes the deal. Over here you can explain why your offer is so great it's worth filling out a form for.

Remember:

  • Bullets are great
  • For spelling out benefits and
  • Turning visitors into leads.

Subscribe to Email Updates

Categories

see all

Follow us on Twitter

Blogs We Follow

At Land's End (Infrastructure)
Being Civil (Infrastructure)
Being Inventive (Manufacturing)
Between the Lines (Design)
Beyond Design (Building)
Cracking The Vault (Manufacturing)
Line//Shape//Design (Autodesk)
Lynn Allen's Blog (Autodesk)
The Revit Clinic (Building)
Up and Ready (Support)
Without A Net (Support)